扫码咨询

新闻动态

首页 >> 新闻动态 >> Part 2: Architecture - Three Roads to a 30:1 Bandwidth Signal Source, and the One We Chose
详细内容

Part 2: Architecture - Three Roads to a 30:1 Bandwidth Signal Source, and the One We Chose

时间:2026-11-11     【原创】

This is Part 2 of a four-part series on designing a 100 MHz–3 GHz broadband frequency source module. Part 1 covered the specification analysis and link budget.

Chapter 2: Architecture — From One Block Diagram to Three Boards

2.1 First, get the channel count and the cascading straight

The requirement says "dual-channel architecture, multi-unit cascade, unified host management," and the interfaces give one RS-422 in and one out. Together, these two facts say this module will be strung out in a row on one bus. I have been burned by cascading before, so let me explain it in advance: RS-422 is a one-transmitter-many-receiver bus. If you short Y/Z and A/B directly through to the next module inside each unit, the waveform starts degrading by the fifth unit and you lose packets by the eighth. The correct approach is a repeater inside each module: the receiver recovers the UART, it passes through isolation into the FPGA, and the FPGA drives the local transmitter to feed the next stage. Addresses are set by DIP switches or resistor ID on the board; the protocol uses a frame format of "address + command + length + checksum." Put 22 Ω resistors in series on the serial lines, terminate both ends of the bus with 120 Ω, and don't terminate the mid-span nodes. None of this is hard to write down, but it must be reserved in the first schematic revision — you cannot bolt it on later.

2.2 Three architectures, side by side

For a wideband signal source there are exactly three roads: direct digital synthesis (DDS/DAC) direct output; PLL plus mixing up-conversion; and the DDS-plus-PLL mixing combination. Let me do the math for all three.

Road one: DAC direct output. A 1 GSPS DAC outputs 0–400 MHz in the first Nyquist zone; to reach 3 GHz you rely on the DAC's higher-Nyquist-zone image — 3 GHz is the third image of 1 GSPS sampling (in the 2.5–3.5 GHz region). DAC output power falls off with the sinc roll-off, roughly 3–4 dB below baseband, and image selection depends on a post-filter — and the filter is the hard part: you need a passband at 2.5–3.5 GHz while rejecting 0–1.5 GHz and everything above 3.5 GHz by 40 dB or more. An LC filter cannot do this; you need a cavity or ceramic filter, and volume and cost go up. The advantages of this road: phase continuity, fast hopping, controllable spurious. The disadvantage: the high end rides on an image, and both amplitude and spurious look bad.

Road two: PLL as the direct carrier, noise as the modulation source. Use a 100–3000 MHz integer/fractional-N PLL as the carrier, and modulate the VCO tuning voltage or the PLL's modulation port with baseband noise via a DAC or analog switch to produce "in-band noise jamming." This road is cheapest and lowest power, but bandwidth is limited by loop bandwidth — a PLL loop bandwidth is typically tens to a few hundred kilohertz. For a 200 MHz noise bandwidth you must bypass the loop and drive the VCO tuning port directly, and the VCO's tuning sensitivity Kv is not constant across the band — low end and high end differ by 3–5× — so the modulation bandwidth shifts with it and flatness cannot be guaranteed. This road suits narrowband spot jamming, not wideband barrage.

Road three: the combined architecture — DAC/DDS makes the IF, PLL makes the LO, IQ modulation up-converts. The DAC produces a 1.2–1.4 GHz IF (200 MHz bandwidth), the LO hops in segments, and after IQ modulation the sum sideband covers 100–3000 MHz. This is the industry-standard approach, and it is the one I finally chose. Advantages: fixed IF, so IF filtering and matching are easy; each LO segment needs only a few frequencies, so PLL lock can be pressed to the 10 µs class; images are handled by the IQ modulator itself plus digital pre-correction, reaching better than 30 dB. The cost: one more mixing stage, an LO source, and another bank of filters — cost and area both go up.

Second decision: the reference source. On the same board there are three clocks — the DAC sample clock, the ADC sample clock, and the PLL reference — and they must share one source; otherwise they drift against each other and the spurious you measure jumps around with temperature. My approach: a single TCXO at 100 MHz (122.88 MHz works equally well) as the only source; it feeds the FPGA's MMCM to derive the DAC and ADC clocks, and also feeds the PLL as reference. One caution: when the DAC uses a parallel interface, its data clock should be produced directly by the same PLL, not by a separate crystal — even a few tens of ppm of difference will, over time, overflow or underrun the data FIFO, and the symptom is a periodic "click" spurious. This looks elementary, but nine out of ten newcomers stumble here.

So road three it is. The chain, in order: after the DAC, a 1.0–1.6 GHz bandpass (or lowpass) filter to suppress the DAC's sinc image (first sidelobe only about 13 dB down) and clock feedthrough; then a VGA doing ±10 dB of digital gain control — the main workhorse of flatness compensation; then the IQ modulator, whose LO comes from the segmented PLL; after the modulator, a switch-selected three-segment filter bank (100–500, 500–1500, 1500–3000 MHz); then the digital step attenuator (31.5 dB, 0.5 dB steps) — power fine-trim and sweep amplitude shaping both happen here; then a driver stage plus final stage of wideband amplification; after the final stage, a 16 dB directional coupler — one tap feeds the detector for closed-loop control, the other goes out; and no limiter before the output port — the output end doesn't fear incoming attacks, so clamping is only added between the DAC and the IQ modulator input.

How is the dual channel done? The economical way: one each of DAC, IF filter, and VGA; the LO is shared, split 1:2 to feed two IQ modulators; after that each channel runs its own filter, attenuator, amplifier, and coupler. The two channels' LO phase noise is correlated — a good thing for coherent combining or analog beamforming, and it saves half the LO cost. The more expensive way is two independent LOs, which lets the two channels run different frequencies for dual-band simultaneous jamming. Quote both to the customer; the price difference is about 30%. Let the customer choose — that is the commercial value of "configurable."

2.4 Frequency planning: the easiest place to bury a landmine

In a mixing architecture, the fear is that spurs land in-band, so frequency planning must be done in Excel before any drawing starts. Here is the layout we actually use: IF 1.2–1.4 GHz (200 MHz bandwidth), with LOs at 1.1, 1.7, 2.3, 2.9, 3.5, 4.1, 4.4 GHz. The sum outputs are 100–300, 500–700, 1100–1300, 1700–1900, 2300–2500, and a 2900–3000 segment, with the 1500–3000 band covered by the 4.4 GHz LO using the difference sideband. Every time you change an LO point, the mixer's 2×LO, 3×LO, 2×IF, and LO±2IF combination spurs all move — you must compute each one and check whether it lands inside your passband.

Example: LO 1.7 GHz, IF 1.2–1.4 GHz. (1) 2LO−IF lands at 2.0–2.2 GHz — outside the passband, good. (2) 2IF−LO lands at 0.7–1.1 GHz — right inside the passband of the 500–1500 segment filter. That is a landmine. (3) LO+IF lands at 2.9–3.1 GHz — the unwanted sideband, blocked by downstream filtering. (4) 3LO−2IF lands at 2.3–2.7 GHz — a fifth-order product, generally already weak, but you still have to count it. How do you defuse this mine? The most effective move is to change the IF: set the IF to 800–1000 MHz with the 1.7 GHz LO, and the output is 2.5–2.7 GHz… wait, that now falls against the stopband edge of the 2300–2500 filter, so it has to move again. Drop the LO to 1.5 GHz and the output is 2.3–2.5 GHz, with 2IF−LO landing at 0.1–0.3 GHz, held outside by the 100 MHz highpass and the segment switch — only now is it clean. See the point: frequency planning is an iterative dance among three sets of parameters — IF × LO × segmented filtering — not a one-pass layout. Turn these four spur lines into Excel formulas: change one LO and every position refreshes automatically; in ten minutes you can try a dozen combinations.

First, establish the spur arithmetic: third-order products m×LO±n×IF (m+n=3) are 2LO±IF and LO±2IF; fifth-order are 3LO±2IF, 2LO±3IF, and so on. Their strength is not determined by formulas but by the modulator's LO-RF isolation and the LO drive power: every 3 dB of LO overdrive makes even-order spurs rise faster than odd-order, so drive the LO at the modulator's recommended level and no more.

Next, the image. The IQ modulator's image is simply the unwanted sideband; its suppression depends on amplitude and phase balance. Write the amplitude imbalance as a linear ratio r and the phase quadrature error as Δφ (radians); the ideal image rejection (dB) is approximately 20log[r / √(1−2r·cosΔφ+r²)]. When r≈1 this can be roughly remembered as 20log(Δφ/2): a phase error of 2° (0.035 rad) gives about −35 dBc; 1°, about −41 dBc; 0.5°, about −47 dBc. Amplitude error must be judged separately: a 0.5 dB amplitude imbalance alone gives an image of only about −32 dBc; 0.2 dB, about −40 dBc. Both errors exist simultaneously — take the worse of the two, and keep 3–5 dB of margin for temperature drift. So when I write internal specifications I usually put "image better than −35 dBc across temperature," which corresponds to amplitude within 0.3 dB and phase within 1.5°. To push further you need on-chip calibration or digital predistortion — potentiometers cannot hold against temperature drift.

You must also watch LO leakage: it sits at the LO frequency, and if the LO happens to fall inside another segment's passband, no amount of front-end filtering will stop it — you can only push it down with IQ DC offset trimming (good for 10–15 dB) plus frequency-selective filtering.

One more warning: when the LO is 1.1 GHz and the IF is 1.2–1.4 GHz using the sum sideband, the difference product 0.1–0.3 GHz lands right inside the 100–500 segment's passband. This is the classic trap of "one LO feeding two segments at once" — you must separate them with segmented filtering plus channel enable staggering.

One final rule of experience: this spur table must be computed together with the filter rejection — spur level equals the modulator output spur, minus the filter rejection at that frequency, minus the downstream amplifier's out-of-band gain compression. As long as the result is below −50 dBc, acceptance will basically not go wrong.

2.5 Board splitting: three boards, each with its own duty

95 × 55 mm cannot hold it all, so split into three boards. The first is the RF main board, about 85 × 45 mm, four layers, carrying the IQ modulator, filter bank, attenuator, two amplifier stages, coupler, and detector. This board is pure RF: no digital power trace is allowed to cross the RF zone. The second is the digital and frequency-source board, about 80 × 40 mm, six layers, holding the FPGA, DAC, oscillator, PLL, VCO, and power. It is the noise monster; it is separated from the RF main board by standoffs and a shielded cavity, with only the IF, LO, and control lines crossing between them — all as RF lines or shielded ribbon. The third is the interface board, very small, carrying the RS-422 transceivers, DC jack, I/O-CTRL connectors, ESD parts, and reverse-polarity and surge protection on the power input.

Stack the three boards: the RF main board mounts against the cavity floor, the digital board sits above it, with a shielding partition between them. The benefit: the RF main board's ground plane stays intact, never chopped up by return currents from the digital board. Dual channel then means two RF main boards mounted back to back in two compartments of the same cavity, separated by an aluminum wall that must rise at least 3 mm above the board surface at the SMA centers — otherwise the two channels will couple. Measured isolation reaches 60 dB or better.

A newcomer asks: why not two boards, folding the interface onto the digital board? The answer is serviceability and reusability. The interface board is the most likely casualty of plugging, unplugging, and field wiring; as a separate small board, when it dies you replace a 20-yuan part. And when the next project changes the interface from RS-422 to CAN or gigabit Ethernet, only this one board changes — the RF and digital sections stay untouched. That is the platform mindset, and it should become your habit when building product lines.

Next in this series: Part 3 - component selection, with part numbers and pitfalls.

客服中心
联系方式
18688706870
0755-29210759
- 销售
微信18688706870
seo seo